← Back to blog
Market Insight··9 min read

Lake George & Adirondacks: Maximize Your Rental Amenity ROI

Unlock higher booking rates and nightly prices for your Lake George and Southern Adirondacks rental. Smart amenity investments pay off.

Do Amenities Really Pay Off in Lake George and the Southern Adirondacks?

Yes, they do. Property owners in the Lake George region and the Southern Adirondacks often ask us about the return on investment (ROI) for amenities like hot tubs, private pools, or upgraded kitchens. The answer is clear: strategic amenity investments directly correlate with increased booking rates and higher average daily rates (ADR).

This isn’t just anecdotal. Our data and market analysis for areas like Lake George Village, Bolton Landing, Queensbury, Saratoga Springs, and even destinations further north like Lake Placid, confirm that properties with sought-after amenities consistently outperform those without them. The Adirondack Park's vast appeal, from summer lake activities to winter sports at Gore Mountain or West Mountain, creates year-round demand for well-equipped properties.

What Amenities Drive the Most Value?

Specific amenities stand out for their impact on rental performance in this market:

  • Hot Tubs: A year-round draw. Highly desirable in all seasons, particularly in cooler months or after a day of hiking or skiing. A well-maintained hot tub can increase your ADR by 15-25% and extend your booking season well into the shoulder months.
  • Private Pools: A summer powerhouse. While a larger investment, a private pool in areas around Lake George, Saratoga Lake, or even rural Adirondack settings, can command a 25-40% increase in ADR during peak summer season (June-August). It also significantly boosts booking rates during that period. For properties without lake access, a pool becomes even more critical.
  • Lake Access/Waterfront: The ultimate premium. Direct lake access, a private dock, or even deeded beach rights on Lake George or Schroon Lake, fundamentally changes a property’s value proposition. Expect 30-50%+ increases in ADR and near 100% occupancy during peak season. This isn't an 'add-on' amenity, but a core property feature that defines its market.
  • Pet-Friendly: Broadens your audience. While not a luxury amenity, allowing pets can notably increase bookings, especially for properties designed for family travel. We see a 10-15% boost in occupancy for pet-friendly listings.
  • Fast Wi-Fi & Dedicated Workspace: Post-pandemic essentials. Given the rise of remote work, strong, reliable internet and a comfortable workspace are no longer optional. They are critical for guests seeking a 'workcation' or simply needing to stay connected. No significant ADR increase alone, but lack of it can be a deal-breaker.
  • Modern Kitchen/Appliances: Impacts guest satisfaction and perceived value. A dated kitchen can detract from an otherwise great property. A well-stocked, modern kitchen makes an impression and encourages longer stays. Not a direct ADR driver, but essential for competitive positioning.
  • Outdoor Living Spaces: Decks, patios, fire pits, and outdoor dining areas enhance the guest experience. In a region known for its natural beauty, opportunities to enjoy the outdoors are prized. Can contribute to a 5-10% ADR lift, especially with lake views or mountain backdrops.

When is the Best Time to Invest?

Off-season is typically the best time for major upgrades. For the Lake George and Southern Adirondacks region, this means late fall through early spring (November-April). You'll face less competition for contractors and can have the work completed well before the high-demand summer season kicks in.

Planning is crucial. Lead times for pool installations, for example, can be extensive. Start planning major projects 6-12 months in advance.

How Do Seasonal Patterns Affect Amenity ROI?

The Lake George and Adirondacks market has distinct seasonal patterns:

  • Summer (June-August): Peak demand. Properties are booked solid. Pools and lake access are king. Expect the highest ADRs and occupancy.
  • Fall (September-October): Foliage season. Strong demand, especially for properties with scenic views or access to hiking. Hot tubs become highly desirable.
  • Winter (November-March): Ski season and holiday demand. Properties near Gore Mountain or West Mountain see spikes. Hot tubs and cozy indoor amenities (fireplaces, entertainment) are essential. Lake-focused properties see less demand unless they offer snowmobiling access or proximity to winter events.
  • Spring (April-May): Shoulder season. Demand is lower, but amenities like hot tubs can help bridge the gap and attract early-season visitors.

Amenities that cater to these seasonal demands will generate the highest ROI. A hot tub, for instance, provides a strong return across all four seasons, making it a particularly robust investment.

Can Merit Badge Help Me Evaluate Amenity ROI?

Yes. We specialize in optimizing short-term rental performance in the Lake George and Adirondacks market. Our team provides data-driven insights into which amenities will yield the best returns for your specific property, location (e.g., whether you're in a quiet cove on Lake George or by the bustling shops of Saratoga), and target guest demographic.

We assess:

  • Your property's unique features and existing market position.
  • Local competitor amenities and pricing strategies.
  • Guest demand patterns and reviews in your micro-market.
  • Projected costs versus potential revenue increase.
  • Permitting and operational considerations (e.g., hot tub maintenance, pool compliance).

Our goal is to ensure your investment maximizes your rental income and minimizes vacancy.

FAQs

Q: Is a hot tub worth the maintenance in the Adirondacks?

A: Absolutely. While maintenance is required, the increased nightly rates and extended booking season typically far outweigh the operational costs. It's one of the highest ROI amenities for year-round appeal.

Q: How much more can I charge for properties with lake access on Lake George?

A: Properties with direct lake access or private docks on Lake George can command 30-50%+ higher average daily rates during peak season, alongside significantly higher occupancy and demand.

Q: Should I consider a pool if my property isn't directly on a lake?

A: Yes. If you don't have lake access, a private pool becomes a significant differentiator, especially for summer bookings. It helps compensate for the lack of water access and makes your property a destination in itself.

Q: What's the fastest way to increase my booking rate?

A: Upgrading amenities that cater to year-round demand, such as adding a hot tub, enhancing outdoor living areas, and ensuring top-tier communication and guest service, are among the fastest ways to boost your booking rate.


Considering an amenity upgrade for your Lake George or Southern Adirondacks short-term rental? Let's discuss the potential impact on your revenue. Reach out for a free consultation to review your property's potential.

mharris@meritbadgemgmt.com

Schedule a 30-minute chat

Want a straight answer on your property?

Free 30-minute strategy call. We'll look at your numbers and tell you what's working, what's not, and what we'd change.

Book a Strategy Call